Digital payments in East Africa (Part I): Card payment alternatives

Card payment alternatives in Kenya by pesa-africa

Card payment alternatives in Kenya by pesa-africa

Kenya and East Africa are actively transitioning to cashless payments systems. East Africa’s economies are largely cash based informal economies with its associated costs. Challenges in aggregating national transaction data, consumer spending patterns, tax administration there is really no shortage of incentives.

With no means to track sales, little data is available, and channels are too fragmented for companies to forecast production and distribution with any degree of accuracy.
Niti Bhan

Policy makers, governments, central bankers and the private sector are looking to cash in on the benefits of culturing digital payments for the Kenyan market; a variety of emoney and digital currency payment options thrive in Nairobi – the capital.

Central Bank of Kenya data reveals a total of 10million cards in circulation as at January 2013 in the local card payments industry.

Here is a basket representative of card payment alternatives in Kenya.

Credit Cards

A limited type of credit cards are in use. The usual suspects – Visa, MasterCard, Amex, UnionPay are issued by multiple banks in Kenya – Equity Bank, I&M bank, National Bank, Standard Chartered, Barclays Bank.

Only a handful of banks and third party such as Paynet Group (East africa’s largest card processor) & Paystream do merchant acquiring. I&M Bank is one of them and flaunts this on their website:

I&M Bank has been awarded an e-commerce Acquiring license by Visa International and MasterCard, thus becoming the first bank in this region to qualify to offer this service

Despite heavy advertising, credit card use in Kenya suffers low penetration rates. According to the Central bank of Kenya data, percentage growth in credit cards was a measly 5.6%.

Credit Cards
Charge Cards
Prepaid Card
Debit Card
POS machine
July 2009 108, 049 1,679 280 3,280,485 5,063
October 2010 114,058 1,129 19,641 4,617,459 19,279
% growth 4QT
5.56% (32.76%) 6,914% 40% 280%

This data is from 2010 and the market is a whole lot different now, however. The number of credit cards in Kenya represents a small share of the card market.

Kenyans are averse to credit cards which they feel come with punitive fees and charges. Banks on the other hand set stringent vetting procedures before approving issuance of credit cards to customers
Daily Nation

I put it down to the clunky nature of online payment verifications, fraud incidents and a market that hasn’t yet embraced credit lines of the Visa/MasterCard variety. Certainly not a significant part of the market.

One thing is for sure, cc associated interest rates are not the deterrent – 3% is actually low compared to mobile micro-credit service M-Shwari which charges 7.5%. It is not the card, it is their psyche that has adapted to the phone as a key money management tool.

Prepaid cards (discussed later) tap into the utility of both phone and card.

Although not hugely common in local payments, they still have a role to play in ecommerce where Kenya meets the rest of the world. Ecommerce sites in Kenya can accept credit card payments from around the world through gateways. Look out for part II – online payment gateways.

Prepaid Cards

Mobile phone as a central  management tool by pesa_africa

Mobile phone as a central management tool by pesa_africa

Prepaid cards are an alternative card payment tool and remedy some of the shortcomings of credit cards. Contrary to debit cards, prepaid cards are linked to an identity and bypass the KYC hurdles of registering for bank account. This partly explains 6,900% growth in 16months!

The flexibility it offers the user makes it an apt money management tool – when to add funds, how much to allocate for shopping, travel expenses etc. No fixed costs are incurred if the card is not used; credit cards on the other hand have a fixed charge regardless.

The Nakumatt-Mastercard EMV prepaid card is an example of a card merging shopping loyalty points & eKES in a single wallet. Users redeem points for purchases, ATM withdrawals and online purchases. The issuer guarantees card acceptance at branded merchant POS terminals.

Users identify the prepaid card as cash management tool for their recurring shopping expenses for example. They load up their cards through designated agents at Nakumatt, issuer banks or via mobile wallet service providers.

Transferring funds from an M-PESA Account to a VISA prepaid card has created flexibility much needed by the customers. They are able to set their spending power without borrowing from the banks, at an affordable, yet convenient way
ThinkMpesa Blog

Major shopping retail chains have jumped in on this card craze. Tuskys, Naivas & Uchumi all run card schemes, even going further in partnering with Visa/MasterCard payment networks to expand use of card for international travel.

Nation Hela was a card targeted at international remittances in partnership with Visa – it flopped.

A government mandate to cashless public transport systems has spun out prepaid card alternatives for commuter fares. Equity bank and Google co-launched an NFC prepaid card. The BebaPay Card was designed as a tool for managing regular commute expenses (matatu epayments) & cashing out of the card is not an inherent feature. I wrote about it here. Interestingly it has found use in non-commute payments, like some restaurants which accept BebaPay card payments.

The 1963 prepaid is a seemingly retaliatory move by the Matatu Owners Association (MoA) – in partnership with Safaricom. Notably, the phone is focal in loading up the card via mobile wallets.

Debit Cards

Arguably, one of the most common card types in Kenya. In February, Central Bank of Kenya reported 10.2 million people with debit cards (23% of gen population).

Debit cards let card owners access their checking accounts, ATM withdrawals, merchant POS payments, utility bill payments, bank identity and access to an expansive CICO (Cash in Cash Out) network of agents on the fly.

On Nationa TV EMV shift mandate by KBA deadline by pesa_africa

EMV shift mandate by KBA deadline by pesa_africa

A mandate to shift from magnetic stripes to chip-and-PIN cards was issued by the Kenya Bankers Association which set a deadline for May 2014. Increased fraud rates and security concerns have boosted EMV branded debit cards; chip-and-pin cards are steadily becoming the norm. Additionally, EMV debit cards let users access funds internationally.

Merchant acceptance of debit card payments has been equally well received  – shopping points, hotels, restaurants, even small scale retailers!

In part II, I will take on online payment gateways in East Africa.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Comment/Opinion/Constructive Criticism

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: